Egypt: 'It's Not a Place You Go to Die, but a Place You Go to Suffer' -
Torture and Trafficking in Sinai
By Bianca Orval,
11 March 2014
Analysis
Lawlessness in Egypt's Sinai peninsula allows traffickers and kidnappers to
make a commodity out of human life.
Tel Aviv, Israel: Eyob sits, one hand clenching his knee, the other hidden
in the pocket of his jacket, as he recounts the ordeal he suffered at the
hands of kidnappers in Egypt's Sinai peninsula.
Eyob was attempting to journey from Sudan to Israel, but was taken shortly
after he crossed Sudan's border into Egypt. He and 88 others were captured,
blindfolded and chained down like animals with no idea of what might happen
to them. They were transported to an unknown location where Eyob was told he
would be taken to Israel the next day: that day came 6 months later.
Sadly, Eyob's story is far from unique, and in many ways he was lucky to
have even survived. According to a
<
http://www.eepa.be/wcm/dmdocuments/Small_HumanTrafficking-Sinai2-web-3.pdf>
study published by Tilburg University in December 2013, 25,000 to 30,000
people have been victims of trafficking in Sinai since 2009, of whom
5,000-10,000 have lost their lives.
People become victims of traffickers in two main ways. Many are refugees -
often from Eritrea - who pay smugglers to transport them across the Sinai
peninsula to the Israeli border, while others like Eyob are simply kidnapped
from refugee camps or elsewhere.
Either way, these individuals are taken hostage and held for ransoms worth
tens of thousands of dollars. It is estimated that since 2009, human
trafficking networks in Sinai have generated over $600 million. The
smugglers are typically either from the Rashaida or Hidarib tribe who pass
on their hostages to Bedouin
<
http://www.economist.com/blogs/pomegranate/2013/12/human-trafficking-sinai>
cells in the largely lawless deserts of the Sinai peninsula.
Stories of these practices have been increasing since around 2009, when it
appears criminal networks started move from smuggling humans towards
kidnapping them. More often than not it seems, those held hostage are
tortured while they await their fate too.
"They tied me up with chains so I couldn't resist, and then put melting
plastic on my back," recalls Eyob, who also tells of how his torturers cut
off the fingers on his left hand after he refused to rape some of his fellow
hostages.
According to testimonies from many other victims, it seems brutal beatings,
gang rape and even murder are common occurrences in these 'houses of hell'.
"After they had beaten us for so long, many people died," says one survivor.
"They even gave one of the men who had died to the dogs outside in the
desert," says another. Bareki, another individual who found himself at the
mercy of human traffickers, offers: "It is not a place you go to die, but a
place you go to suffer."
Human Rights Watch has also spoken to many survivors and recently compiled
their similarly heart-rending testimony in the report
<
http://www.hrw.org/reports/2014/02/11/i-wanted-lie-down-and-die-0> I Wanted
to Lie Down and Die.
Complex human trafficking networks have also been linked to the organ trade
industry though relatively little attention has been focussed on this issue.
"They will take your organs if you don't pay them what they want," says
Eyob.
Despite testimonies from victims making their way into the media and
pressure from human rights groups, there remains little evidence that
governments are taking the necessary actions to tackle the problem.
Former Egyptian president Mohammed Morsi's
<
http://www.cfr.org/egypt/egypts-sinai-peninsula-security/p32055> order to
security forces to claim control over the area proved frustrating, with 16
Egyptian soldiers killed in attacks in 2012.
And the militarised
<
http://thinkafricapress.com/egypt/generals-turn-old-rival-fight-against-ans
ar-bayt-al-maqdes-sudan-sinai> efforts of Egypt's new de facto leader, Field
Marshall Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, to clamp down on militants in the region do
not seem to have had much success either and have arguably even backfired.
Eyob is just one of many individuals that have experienced the reality of
human trafficking in Sinai. His physical scars bear witness to the cruelty
that continues to occur, while his memories remain barricaded behind
feelings of survivors' guilt.
Perhaps the most tragic aspect of his story, however, is how it is far from
unique. Thousands have endured the same fear, pain and torture as Eyob, and
unless governments coordinate to disrupt what has become a safe haven for
traffickers, many thousands more will too.
Received on Tue Mar 11 2014 - 13:59:41 EDT