From: wolda002@umn.edu
Date: Thu Jun 17 2010 - 00:27:33 EDT
It is time for Asia to rewrite the rules of capitalism
By Chandran Nair
Published: June 16 2010 01:50 | Last updated: June 16 2010 01:50
The 20th century’s triumph of consumption-based capitalism has created
the crisis of the 21st century: looming catastrophic climate change,
massive environmental damage and significant depletion of natural
resources. Asia is now at the heart of it.
The western economic model, which defines success as consumption-driven
growth, must be challenged. Asia, while apparently promising most for this
model’s continuation because of its large population, is paradoxically
the region best placed to do this.
Advocates of the western model tend to play down its dramatic effects on
natural resources and the environment. They refuse to acknowledge that
their advice runs counter to scientific consensus about limits and the need
for stringent rules on resource management.
Instead, they argue that human ingenuity aided by innovations in the
markets will find solutions. This is rooted in an irrational belief that we
can have everything: ever-growing material wealth and a healthy natural
environment. The stark evidence in Asia, where the majority has not even
begun to consume to its potential, should be proof enough that this is not
possible. Yet denial continues.
Imagine a world in which, by 2050, four to five billion Asians are
consuming like Americans. The result would be catastrophic, yet this is
what Asians are being told to aspire to. As Asia rises, the two billion now
at the margins of the consumption economy will radically transform global
demand and supply, not only for non-renewable commodities such as oil and
coal, but also for renewables such as food. This is no Malthusian rehash.
Asian political leaders must demonstrate leadership. The western emphasis
on markets, technology and finance cannot deliver. Do Asian leaders allow
western-style economic freedoms to flourish and witness the destruction of
the world, or demand stronger action by governments to ensure these
mechanisms deliver a sustainable – and fairer – future?
Many experts offer answers that do not confront the reality of resource
constraints. Typically, they prescribe market solutions combined with
technology and financial tools such as emission trading schemes.
Yet politicians must recognise that technology cannot provide all the
answers. Blue fin tuna, if fished to extinction, cannot be recreated in a
petri dish. Nor can business be expected to lead the way in this area. The
new rules needed to change the way people consume may spell the end for
some companies, and they will fight to prevent change.
This is why Asian governments must intervene. Limits must be placed on
various forms of consumption, with policies put in place to enforce them.
This starts with access to resources and the rights to various forms of
consumption. Their core task is to rewrite the rules of capitalism – by
putting resource constraints at the centre of policymaking.
Governments have two key mechanisms at their disposal. First, negative
environmental externalities, currently excluded from the cost of many goods
and services, must be priced in through the imposition of taxes and fees
and the removal of subsidies. Second, caps must be put on the use of
resources that are being overexploited, including, where appropriate,
outright bans on use. With these tools, consumption can be controlled and
where necessary reduced.
Policymakers need to challenge the vested interests arguing that
consumption-driven capitalism is the only course and that any alternative
will lead to poverty and unemployment. As they do so, they should make
clear that this does not mean people can no longer aspire to be prosperous.
It means rather that expectations must be aligned with the constraints
under which all societies operate – but Asian ones above all.
Asian governments must take responsibility for current and future
generations. They must demonstrate that what they are doing is not only
necessary but equitable – and therefore legitimate.
Suggesting a future in which economic policy is framed around limits,
restraint and restrictions is to invite controversy, but Asian governments
must start down this road. They have no choice. They will be held
account-able not just by their own citizens but by the world at large.
The author is chief executive of the Global Institute for Tomorrow. His
book ‘Consumptionomics: Asia’s Role in Reshaping Capitalism and Saving
the Planet’ is due out in October
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2010. Print a single copy of this
article for personal use. Contact us if you wish to print more to
distribute to others.
----[This List to be used for Eritrea Related News Only]----