webmaster
© Copyright DEHAI-Eritrea OnLine, 1993-2010
All rights reserved
From: Ghidewon@aol.com
Date: Wed Sep 22 2010 - 11:19:09 EDT
Crisis Group's Latest Report on Eritrea: Garbage In, Garbage Out
Ghidewon Abay Asmerom
September 22, 2010
"GIGO" as an abbreviation for "Garbage In, Garbage Out" is a common phrase
among computer programmers. It illustrates the fact that "computers will
unquestioningly process the most nonsensical of input data (garbage in) and
produce nonsensical output (garbage out)." This is exactly what the latest
Crisis Group report on Eritrea did. Despite a semblance and camouflage of
professionalism, it is a report that has recycled refuse that has been out
in the dumpster for the past nine years.
One doesn't have to go further than the footnotes to see the source of the
trash. It is the same rubbish that was previously collected at the waste
receptacles called the Chatham House, the Red Sea Press, the Oslo Center, or
an exclusive conference in Belgium. Any genuine analyst would have
immediately realized that the collection was meant for shipment to a landfill, not
for use in a high-caliber analysis. However, not to the judgment of ICG
analysts "in another capacity!" They have chosen to package it afresh hoping
the junk will stick better this time around.
Who are the people quoted as sources by the report? There are those who
"have an axe to grind" and a long term grudge against the Eritrean government.
Some are "agent handlers", who were caught with their pants down. Others
are pseudo experts with zero-knowledge of the intricacies of the area and
without even the minimum knowledge of the languages the people whose lives
they are trying to screw; their sole interest is to get academic papers or
thesis that potential referees will not pick to pieces. There also three
people known for their outright hostility against Eritrea's right to
self-determination with their record of smear campaign and wrong analysis going back
to 35, 25 to 15 years. They were wrong then and are wrong today.
Of course the chief source of the stench is a phantom source cited 40 times
in the footnotes and conveniently labeled as: "Crisis Group analyst's
interviews/field notes while in another capacity." In what "another capacity"
was this ghost analyst in Eritrea? In a diplomat, journalist, NGO-operative,
or missionary? Why are we not told about it? Talk of transparency! Could
it be the whole report was outsourced and that ICG is not comfortable enough
to tell the truth to its readers.
This is not the first time for an "Eritrea is doomed" analysis to be
pronounced. Eritreans have been subjected to such kind of propaganda decade
after decade for more than 70 years. From the Chief British Administrator of
Eritrea, who had declared as early as 1945: "the single Eritrea of to-day is
doomed. Dismemberment, in some form and to some extent, must be the
alternative," to an Israeli historian who predicted in 1982: "Eritrean victory
may realistically be excluded as a future possibility. The chances of those
identified with Eritrean nationalism achieving it by military victory over
the Ethiopian armed forces seems very remote," to a Briton who in 2003
stated: "Contrary to a superficial judgment that may treat the BCEE [sic]
allocation as favouring Eritrea over Ethiopia, this allocation is in my view
particularly catastrophic for Eritrea; indeed, it seems to me to go a long way
towards destroying Eritrea's future as a viable independent state." Eritrea
has proved all these wrong. The same is going to be true with this "dooms
report" of the ICG.
Presenting a farrago of lies and recycling known slurs against the Eritrean
Revolution, its Government and President has turned the ICG report more of
a propaganda piece rather than a credible report worth anyone's dime. It
is a report designed to shore up Ethiopia's ugly image and detract Eritrea
from its steady path to chart its own future of progress and development. It
didn't work in the past and it will not work today. Thus this ICG report
should be destined to where it belongs: a landfill. After all it was
collected from a refuse, "Garbage In", and is a mound of rubbish, "Garbage Out."
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------
Join our World-wide E-SMART Movement
Eritrean Sanctions Must be Annulled and Repealed Today!
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------
----[This List to be used for Eritrea Related News Only]----