A Blessing in Disguise:
The Presence of UN Personnel and Peace Keeping Troops in Eritrea
By
Ogbazgy Abbay Asmerom
December 8, 2000
"By centering our lives on correct principles
and creating a balanced focus between doing and increasing our ability
to do, we become empowered in the task of creating effective, useful, and
peaceful lives ... for ourselves, and for posterity. "
--- Stephen Covey --
There is a Tigrigna expression: " To get what you did not expect would
be either a blessing or a curse."
I believe the presence of The United Nations (hereafter UN) personnel
and the Peace- Keeping Forces( code name - UNMEE) in Eritrea would be a
blessing in disguise. I do not see it being a curse, provided that there
will not be any long- lasting peaceful settlement between Tigray, the northern
province of Ethiopia, and Eritrea.
The Tigriyans (present rulers of Ethiopia) rejected the presence of
the peace keeping forces. Eritrea accepted them, because of its desire
to secure a permanent demarcation of the border area. The demarcation and
delimitation of the 620 miles long border area is the ultimate goal for
Eritrea. Hence, Eritrea will have a secured and an ambiguous border with
Ethiopia.
It is to be recalled Eritrea is not new to foreigners. Hundreds of years
ago, several invading foreigners have set their feet in Eritrea: the Turks
(1557-1860), the Egyptians (1860-1888), the Italians (1888-1941), the British
(1941-1952) and the Ethiopians (1952-1991). They were colonizers. They
did not come to Eritrea to bring peace. They came to invade and to rule
over the local population.
Eritrea has learned some lessons from each one of those foreigners.
Some had positive influence, and others have negative influence. Especially,
Ethiopian rule was the most bizarre and unproductive one. Someone has said,
"the Ethiopians made the Eritrean mind and stomach empty." Thus, there
was no good thing that came out of Ethiopian rule.
When UNMEE fully deploys its 4,200 troops in Eritrea, hopefully, the
2 ½ -year old war that ate the economies of the two countries, will
end with the demarcation of the disputed territories. Therefore, finally,
peace may come to the two most wretched countries of the Horn of Africa.
There is some hope that a comprehensive peace agreement will be signed
on December 12, 2000, in Algiers, Algeria. The concerned parties: Eritrea,
Ethiopia, The Organization of Africa Unity (hereafter OAU), the European
Union (hereafter EU), The UN, United States of America (hereafter USA)
will be present during the historic signing agreement of the 2 ½
years old conflict, which started on May 6, 1998.
Therefore, let us hope, against all odds, and wish this agreement
will be the last peace agreement to be signed between the two antagonists.
Everybody is expecting a positive outcome.
It is expected the President of Eritrea, Isaias Afewerki, the Prime
Minister of Ethiopia, Meles Zenawi, and the Secretary-General of the UN,
Kofi Annan, may be present at the signing of the Peace Agreement. This
will be a historic meeting. The Horn of Africa may see a new beginning.
If peace is to come to the region, it should only come from within Eritrea
and Ethiopia. Eritrea and Ethiopia must be at peace with each other and
within themselves and should find a way to solve their problems. The 3rd
parties can only be observers and not directly benefactors of the Cessation
of Hostilities. They are not the main instruments, but only facilitators.
The OAU, EU, UN and USA do not have a vested interest in the welfare
of the two societies. With the exception of the OAU and UN, the others
are mainly interested in their vital and national interests. They sell
their weapons to let the killing continue. They need new markets to sell
their products. They need raw materials to build their economies. As we
know, in politics, there are no permanent friends, but permanent national
interests.
The UN Security Council has approved the presence of 4,200 of its personnel
and troops to be stationed inside Eritrean territory, so that the hostilities
of the two countries would come to an end and peace would prevail.
Various officers, emissaries and troops have began arriving in Eritrea.
Their main mission is to maintain the Cessation of Hostilities signed between
Eritrea and Ethiopia on June 18, 2000. They do not prevent the two parties
from fighting. Eritrea and Ethiopia must choose not to fight and maintain
the peace accord.
It is good to see the presence of troops and UNMEE personnel from various
nationalities coming to Eritrea and moving around Asmara, the western,
eastern and southern parts of Eeritrea. It is expected by the first quarter
of next year (2001), there will be about 4,200 UN personnel and troops
stationed inside Eritrea. Most of the Peace- keeping troops will be in
the Temporary Security Zones (hereafter TSZ), which are inside Eritrea.
Some of the UN personnel and soldiers will be in the urban areas of
Eritrea, including: Asmara, Dekemhare, Mendefera, Adi Quala, Adi Keyih,
Barentu, Om Hajer, Senafe, Asseb and many other peripheral and border areas.
It is a matter of fact that there are many parts of Eastern, Southern
and Western Eritrea still under the occupation of the Leaders of Tigray
and Ethiopia. The civilian inhabitants, those who did not get a chance
to go to the safest areas of Eritrea, are under the brutal rule of the
Tigriyan rag-tag soldiers.
Since the invasion of those areas, on May 12, 2000, up to the present
time, a lot of damage has been done by the invading forces. Churches, mosques,
schools, shops, hospitals, hotels and private homes have been destroyed.
Livestock animals have been taken into captivity.
The infrastructure of those areas has been destroyed. A lot of property
has been looted. Some have been burned. Some of have been moved to Tigray
as a war booty. About 1.5 million Eritreans have been displaced. More than
75,000 Eritreans have been forcefully deported from Ethiopia and Tigray.
Their properties have been confiscated. Many Eritreans have lost their
businesses. The value of the confiscated property is estimated to be more
than $800,000.000.00.
It is also documented by the various humanitarian agencies that hundreds
of Eritrean young girls and married women have been raped by the invading
army of Tigray. This is the highest crime against civilians and should
be punished.
It is possible some of those rape victims may be infected with HIV/AIDS,
the scourge of the century, which is prevalent in the invading Ethiopian
army. Hence, Eritrean women will have a scar that will not be healed for
generations to come.
The 4,200 UN personnel or troops will, on a daily basis, transmit pieces
of information and reports about Eritrea and the Eritrean people to their
individual families, governments, countries and The UN Headquarters. Some
of them will be positive, and others will undoubtedly be critical and negative.
Here are some of the things that the Eritrean government should consider
when it comes to the daily interaction with the UN personnel and troops:
-
Give UNMEE access to all of the non-sensitive areas and let them move freely
and patrol the TSZ
-
Cooperate with the UN personnel on a professional level
-
Coordinate all activities that would facilitate the quick withdrawal of
Ethiopian troops from Eritrean territories
-
Show a sense of diplomatic tact that is equal to what is practiced in other
places and at higher circles or levels
-
Show a sense of confidence and determination in what should be done
-
Scheduled appointments and commitments given should be respected
-
Set the priorities for the reconstruction and rehabilitation of the damaged
infrastructure
-
Avoid any form of bribery, corruption and impropriety
-
Show and tell what has been destroyed by the Weyanes of Tigray and leaders
of Ethiopia
-
Explain fully and unequivocally what kind of help would be needed to resuscitate
and rebuild the shattered economy
-
Understand that the UN Personnel will not solve all of our problems that
we may have with the Weyanes or Ethiopians
-
Watch and monitor that the Eritrean RED SEA COAST should not be a damping
site of waste materials
-
Confirm and emphasize that Eritrean customs, religions, traditions and
culture are respected by UNMEE
-
Emphasize Eritrea's full determination is to have the border demarcated
and delineated. There should not be any compromise on that.
-
Be aware of the need to have a positive image of Eritrea in the world and
maintain it
-
Avoid any form of gullibility and stay away from diplomatic traps and gaffes
-
Make it clear there is no substitute to peace and war is not a solution
to any border crisis
-
Be flexible when it comes to the essential requests for adjustment and
compromise
The Eritrean masses will, in one way or another, come in contact with the
UN personnel and troops. Here are some of the things that should be considered:
-
Accept the facts that the UN personnel are not different in any way, shape
or form from the rest of the Eritrean people. They are not angles or saints
to be worshiped
-
Small children should not consider the UN personnel as aliens from Mars
or Jupiter
-
There should not be any sense of dependency or desperation
-
The privacy of the UN personnel, troops and their property should be respected
-
Give answers to pertinent question with confidence and integrity
-
Know that the UN personnel are facilitators of peace, and not peace themselves
-
Understand that each Eritrean will serve as a mirror on the wall to be
checked
-
Show a sense of national pride and love of country
-
Learn some of the positive aspects of the UNMEE, not the negative aspects
-
Make it clear that self-sufficiency and self-reliance are the pillars of
economic independence
-
Accept the fact that the UN personnel are our quests and should be treated
with respect and good hospitality
-
Know that these UN personnel do not perform miracles or magic
-
Show them the positive aspects of our culture, religions, history and spirit
of self-reliance
-
Avoid any sense of arrogance and insensitivity
-
There should not be tatter- tale about our domestic problems
-
Young men and women should be careful when it comes to youthful indiscretions
and liaisons
The Eritrean people should expect the following things from the 4,200 UN
Personnel:
-
All Eritrean institution should be respected
-
There should not be any unnecessary intrusion into our national honor and
identity
-
Relationships and friendships, if established, should be based on mutual
respect and benefits
-
There should not be any manifestation of ethnocentrism or any form of ethnic
superiority
-
Accept that the Eritrean people have enough words and means of communication
to express themselves
-
The positive, not only the negative, images of Eritrea and the Eritrean
people should be emphasized and be reported
-
There should not be any tilting or distorting of facts and figures that
seem to favor the Weyanes of Ethiopia
-
The affairs of Eritrea should be given equal and fair treatment when compared
to Ethiopia's affairs
-
The presence of the OAU and the Economic Commission for Africa (ECA) in
Addis Abeba should not have any impact upon the decision making process
of the UNMEE Officers
-
The UNMEE officers and personnel should be impartial and fair in the way
they report about the situation in Eritrea
-
The UNMEE should enforce the quick withdrawal of Ethiopian troops from
occupied and undisputed Eritrean territories
-
The UNMEE should check and clear all of the buried land mines
-
As guests of the Eritrean people, UNMEE should not take the hospitality
of the people for granted
-
Payment should be made for any services provided or rendered
-
Any contracts or agreements negotiated with the Eritreans should be kept
and respected
-
There should not be any form of espionage and malfeasance
-
There should not be any form of exploitation and intimidation
-
Any misunderstanding or disputes should be resolved by mutual respect,
open dialogue and transparency
As I said earlier, the presence of UN personnel and troops in Eritrea
will be a blessing in disguise. Here are the possible blessings or benefits:
-
The Eritrean case will be internationalized
-
Eritrean territorial integrity will be maintained and will be respected
-
The OAU, EU, UN, and USA will have a better understanding of the skills
and industriousness of the Eritreans
-
Possibly, Eritrea will have 4,200 new UNMEE friends
-
More counties of the world will know, learn, and understand the psyche
of Eritrea
-
More Africans, Asians, South Americans and Europeans will learn about the
history, culture, religions, geography and economy of Eritrea
-
The Eritrean case will no longer be a hidden agenda and an issue in the
corridors of the UN, OAU, EU and USA
-
The EU and the USA will have a better understanding of the 30 - year old
struggle of Eritrea
-
More aid and foreign assistance may come to Eritrea
-
The destroyed Eritrean infrastructure will be rebuilt
-
Ultimately, the border between Eritrea and Ethiopia will be demarcated
and will have visible physical marks to be known for posterity
-
Eritreans who lost properties due to the confiscation by Ethiopian authorities
will be compensated
-
Divided Eritrean families will be united. There will not be any Eritrean
orphans to be left in Ethiopia and Tigray
-
Displaced Eritreans and refugees will be returned, repatriated and rehabilitated
-
Detained civilians and Prisoners of War (POWs) will be released
-
The psychological wounds of Eritreans will be healed in due time
-
Ethiopia's desire to have an access to the sea will be thwarted
-
The dream of Greater Tigray, at the expense of Eritrea, will be evaporated
-
Many countries and people outside of Eritrea will know about the genesis
of the 2 ½ - year old war and its effect on the civilian population
-
The Ethiopian invading troops will withdraw from occupied and undisputed
Eritrean territories and the evil actions of the Weyanes will be exposed
-
The fate of Eritrean Quislings and Traitors will be doomed
-
Ethiopia will no longer be the bully of the Horn of Africa
-
The Eritreans will learn some valuable lessons from each one of the 4,2000
UN personnel
-
Some technical skills and know- how will be introduced to Eritrea by UNMEE
-
The future of Eritrea will be brighter and secured
-
The national unity of Eritreans will be strengthened
-
Eritrean institutions may be strengthened, democraticized and be modernized
-
The future of the Eritrean Peoples Front for Democracy and Justice (EPFDJ)
will be changed
-
The Eritrean Defense Forces will be strengthened and be modernized. Eritrea
will have a better equipped and trained national army
-
Eritreans will learn more about world diplomacy and the interdependence
of nations
-
The UN will remain seized by the Eritrean issue
-
The UN cartographers will do a better job in identifying the original boundaries
between Eritrea and Ethiopia
-
There may be a long-lasting peace between Eritrea and Ethiopia. Hopefully,
there will not be any future war between the two poorest countries of the
Horn of Africa
-
The OAU may redeem itself from being ineffective and can use the Eritrean
and Ethiopian Peace Accord card to resolve the other African problems,
mainly the ones that are going on in Sierra Leone, Angola, Rwanda, Somalia,
The Sudan and the Democratic Republic of the Congo
-
Eritrea will be a major power in the Red Sea littoral. Its trade with the
Middle East will flourish
-
There may be an overhauling peace process in the entire Horn of Africa
-
New political realignments and rapprochement may be conceivable in the
Red Sea area
Thus, the presence of the 4,200 UN personnel in Eritrea will bring some
benefits and blessings that we never imagined. At this moment in history,
we need to seize the opportunity and allow ourselves to be part of the
new political realignment and reconfiguration. Finally, peace may be at
hand. Hope may be restored.
The confidence level of every Eritrean should be elevated to its highest
level. This is an opportune time to reflect and think about our successes
and failures and move forward on the road that leads to prosperity and
political maturity.
As LaRochefoucauld observed:
"there is a kind of greatness which does not
depend upon fortune; it is certain manner that distinguishes, and which
seems to destine us for great things; it is the value we insensibly set
upon ourselves; it is by this quality, that we gain the deference of other
men, and it is this which commonly raises us more above them, than birth,
rank, or even merit itself."